By ANNE QUISMORIO, MD, MPH
SHUNTARO SHINADA, MD
RICHARD S. PANUSH, MD |
October 9, 2011
http://www.musculoskeletalnetwork.com/display/article/1145622/1963047
The Journal of Musculoskeletal Medicine.
Vol. 28
No. 10
PRINCIPLES OF CARE
Goals
of therapy include the restoration and preservation of patients'
physical independence by providing symptomatic relief and maintaining
quality of life and function. The ultimate goals are to halt disease
progression (have “disease-modifying” therapy for OA), reverse
established disease, achieve “cures,” and prevent disease. However, the
current therapies, although usually helpful, are only palliative. Thus,
the basic principles for managing OA pain (Table 1) are as follows:
•
Confirm the diagnosis. Do not miss calcium pyrophosphate dihydrate
crystal deposition disease, inflammatory arthritis, erosive/inflammatory
OA, polymyalgia rheumatica (PMR), fibromyalgia syndrome (FMS) (alone or
superimposed), associated depression, neurological or vascular disease,
endocrinological disease (thyroid or parathyroid), chronic pain
syndromes (eg, complex regional pain syndrome), tendinitis/bursitis (do
not confuse epicondylitis with elbow disease, de Quervain tenosynovitis
with wrist arthritis, anserine bursitis with knee arthritis, or
trochanteric bursitis with hip disease), ochronosis, or hemochromatosis.
When in doubt, obtain expert consultation.
• Seek preventable or reversible underlying or primary disease.
•
Identify the site or sites of OA. Disease may be “generalized” but
often is localized to specific joints, such as the distal
interphalangeal (DIP), first metacarpophalangeal (MCP), first
carpometacarpophalangeal (CMC), axial skeleton, hip, knee (Figure), and first metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joints.
•
Use reasonable clinical judgment in assessing patients. Experienced
clinicians usually recognize OA readily without obtaining extensive
diagnostic studies. Plain x-ray films usually are sufficient to identify
anatomical abnormalities. Serological studies usually are not
necessary, and they may simply introduce confusion—rheumatoid arthritis,
systemic lupus erythematosus, and other rheumatologic disorders may be
excluded with a thoughtful, thorough, informed clinical evaluation
without laboratory testing.
• Begin therapy with patient
education, explanation, discussion of prognosis, and nonpharmacological
modalities. Many patients feel relieved to learn that their disease is
not necessarily rapidly progressive or destructive. Patients can benefit
from various nonpharmacological strategies.
Because obesity is a
risk factor for the development and progression of OA, patients should
be counseled on weight loss. Exercise programs should be tailored to
individual patients.
Attention to footwear, gait, and ambulation
may result in symptomatic improvement. Patients should be educated about
the proper use of walking aids because they may help reduce hip and
knee OA pain.
Useful adjuncts to management include help with
activities of daily living, activity modification, quadriceps
strengthening exercises, patellar taping, and formal programs of
occupational and physical therapy. Some patients cope better and some
symptoms may be minimized with cognitive-behavioral therapy or formal
counseling.
• Pharmacological therapy, if needed, begins with
acetaminophen (up to 4 g/d). NSAIDs also are beneficial but should be
used at the lowest effective dose. The advantage of acetaminophen over
NSAIDs is its safety profile. Because NSAIDs have been associated with
GI and renal adverse effects, they should be used with caution in
patients who have underlying cardiovascular, renal, or GI disease. The
response to a specific NSAID differs from one patient to another.
Cyclooxygenase (COX)-2 inhibitors, such as celecoxib(Drug information on celecoxib),
may be preferable for patients who have a history of GI ulcers, are
receiving anticoagulation therapy, or have a bleeding diathesis. NSAIDs
may be added as clinically indicated for younger patients and perhaps
patients who do not have comorbid medical problems, are also taking
corticosteroids or anticoagulants, and did not have previous ulcer
disease or GI bleeding. To prevent GI adverse effects, a COX-2 selective
inhibitor or a nonselective NSAID together with misoprostol(Drug information on misoprostol)
or a proton pump inhibitor may be prescribed. We also might prescribe a
nonacetylated salicylate (disalicylate, choline magnesium
trisalicylate).
For persistently symptomatic joints for which
injections are feasible, intra-articular corticosteroids or hyaluronan
may be considered. If there is persistent pain, tramadol(Drug information on tramadol)
also should be considered. This regimen should provide satisfactory
symptomatic relief for most patients with OA. Additional pharmacological
treatments include some topical medications (capsaicin cream and diclofenac(Drug information on diclofenac) patch or ointment) that also may be quite useful for specific painful or tender areas.
•
Whenever possible, manage monarticular or oligoarticular disease with
topical or local therapies or both, avoiding unnecessary systemic
medications.
• Other approaches to treatment that have been suggested to provide benefit include acupuncture, pregabalin(Drug information on pregabalin), gabapentin(Drug information on gabapentin), milnacipran, and duloxetine(Drug information on duloxetine).
Many clinicians now consider glucosamine and chondroitin to have no
important clinical value, but they are generally safe and well-tolerated
and some patients do report benefit. In our opinion, there is
insufficient evidence to support nonexperimental use of tidal lavage,
platelet-rich plasma therapy, or herbal and other complementary and
alternative medicines for patients with OA.
• We do not recommend
routine or long-term use of narcotic analgesics for managing patients
with OA. Although these medications are effective for pain management,
they should be used rarely and only in patients who are refractory to
other pharmacological treatments. Narcotic analgesics should be
prescribed by physicians who are experienced in caring for persons
receiving these agents.
• Some surgical procedures for appropriate joints in select patients can result in dramatic benefit.
GENERAL APPROACHES
How to approach patients with "pain all over"?
OA
should not cause diffuse, nonlocalized pain; patients who complain of
this should be assessed for other or associated conditions. For patients
with OA, the symptoms should be correlated with disease in specified
joints.
For example, widespread pain may reflect FMS; PMR; other
arthopathies or rheumatologic disease; endocrinological or metabolic
disorders; neuropathy; vascular disease; central sensitization syndrome;
or OA of the shoulders, knees, hips, or axial skeleton, and there also
might be bursitis or tendinitis. A careful evaluation can clarify this.
When sites with OA are identified and specific symptoms are related to
them, rational and individualized therapeutic approaches can be
developed that are most likely to be successful, and the ordering of
expensive and extensive imaging studies and then prescribing something
such as Tylenol #3 can be avoided.
OA can affect multiple joints,
especially the DIP joints, proximal interphalangeal (PIP) joints, CMC
joints, MTP joints, cervical and lumbar spine facet joints, knees, and
hips. Many patients who have OA of the DIP or PIP joints may have
physical abnormalities that are asymptomatic. A few patients may have
“inflammatory” OA, usually of the hands, with an elevated erythrocyte
sedimentation rate or C-reactive protein level. They may benefit from hydroxychloroquine(Drug information on hydroxychloroquine) or NSAIDs.
How to approach patients with localized or oligoarticular OA?
These
patients may be treated initially with nonmedicinal approaches, such as
physical therapy and local heat therapy. They also may derive benefit
from topical therapies, alternatives to oral NSAIDs that include
diclofenac gel and diclofenac patch. Lidocaine(Drug information on lidocaine) patches and topical menthol(Drug information on menthol)- and capsaicin-based creams also may provide relief, albeit temporary.
Local
injection with corticosteroids may be used for patients who have severe
pain in 1 or 2 joints. The goal is to provide short-term, temporary
relief of OA pain; this usually does not provide long-lasting, permanent
relief. Injection of hyaluronic acid into affected joints also may be
beneficial for select patients. Patients who do not respond to these may
benefit from systemic medical therapies. Acetaminophen may provide
symptomatic relief for patients who have OA pain (Table 2).
APPROACHES FOR SPECIFIC JOINTS
Primary
OA affects a typical distribution of joints, such as the cervical spine
or lumbar spine. OA of other joints should alert the physician to a
possible secondary OA.
Hands/wrists. Although PIP and DIP
OA can be unsightly, it usually is asymptomatic and may not cause
discomfort, pain, or disability. Conservative therapy with local heat or
paraffin(Drug information on paraffin)
baths or topical therapies may provide pain relief. Local
corticosteroid injections can reduce pain but may be difficult without
ultrasonographic guidance to ensure proper localization. Seldom would a
patient require joint fusion surgery for severe pain at the PIP or DIP
joints. Acetaminophen or NSAID therapy or both may also provide
temporary relief, especially when the joints are symptomatic.
The
first CMC joint may be problematic because it is used in grasping and
pinching and for almost every activity that involves the hand. Patients
often lose strength in their fingers and may need assistive devices to
complete their activities of daily living. A custom splint worn at
nighttime can ease the pain. Local corticosteroid injections usually are
of limited benefit. The potential for surgical intervention is limited
by the need to use this joint in everyday life.
Shoulders.
Primary OA of the shoulder does not occur often. Degenerative changes
of the glenohumeral joint should prompt the physician to consider that
OA may be the result of another cause (eg, trauma, previous infection,
neuropathy or radiculopathy, crystal deposition disease). If
corticosteroid injections are ineffective or contraindicated, hyaluronic
acid injections may be beneficial for glenohumeral joint arthritis.
Ultrasonographic guidance is recommended.
Hips. OA of the
hip causes pain and disability for many patients. Corticosteroid and
hyaluronic acid injections may be of benefit. When conservative,
physical, systemic, and injection therapies are ineffective, surgical
intervention with total hip arthroplasty should be considered.
Knees. Knee OA is a common problem. As in other joints, local heat, physical measures, and topical therapies may be beneficial.
We
recommend quadriceps strengthening and range of motion exercises,
although their value has been questioned. Glucosamine may be only
slightly beneficial to patients who have mild knee OA. Corticosteroid
and hyaluronic acid injections may provide temporary relief for patients
who have contraindications to surgical intervention.
Attention to
lower extremity biomechanics is important. Some patients are helped by
assisted ambulation, orthoses, and braces. Surgery is indicated when
pain becomes severe and diminished function and quality of life become
unacceptable to the patient. Radiographic changes associated with knee
OA usually are not good indicators for the necessity of surgery;
however, when these changes are associated with refractory pain
disability, surgical intervention should be considered. Total knee
arthroplasty usually is preferable to arthroscopic and partial knee
arthroplasties for knee OA.
Feet. OA of the feet usually
involves the first MTP joint and presents as a bunion or hallux valgus.
This condition can be exacerbated in patients who wear narrow or
high-heeled shoes. Wide-fitting shoes or orthoses help reduce the valgus
deformity, which may reduce pain. Surgery is indicated when recommended
therapeutic measures prove to be ineffective.
Neck/back. The principles of care outlined above apply to OA of the axial skeleton. See the “Bibliography” for more information.
SUMMARY
We
counsel patients with OA to have reasonable expectations, and we
express confidence that we have therapies that will improve their lives.
For patients who have one or a few joints involved, we try largely
physical, topical, and injection therapies, sparing them systemic
medications. For those who are still symptomatic or have multiple-joint
involvement, we include systemic therapy. Most patients can be helped. A
few may need referral for more expert consultation.
Current Approaches to Pain Management for Patients With Osteoarthritis Principles of care and an evidence basis have provided effective treatment
- Selasa, 18 September 2012
Langganan:
Posting Komentar (Atom)
0 komentar:
Posting Komentar